Audiences seemed to have mixed feelings about the songs performed in Joker Folie a Deux. This might have to do with the fact that the original film was not a musical and the unexpected addition to the serious drama feels a little out of place. The original film was not even meant to have a sequel, but maybe having Lady Gaga sign on to play the iconic Harley Quinn, was a musical opportunity that director Todd Phillips couldn’t pass up. But just because Gaga’s voice is incredible doesn’t mean that’s enough to make this film worth the watch.

Joker: Folie a Deux follows Arthur Fleck while in Arkham and awaiting trial for his crimes as Joker. While struggling with his dual identity, he not only stumbles upon true love with Harley Quinn, but also finds the music that’s always been inside him. It’s upsetting to say that this film is probably not at all what fans will be expecting. Gaga fans should be warned from the start, she is severely underutilized. However, what we do see of her and Joaquin Phoenix is still incredible. The problem is not the performances, it’s the material these actors were given. The lack of substance and purpose, makes the sequel struggle to find the energy and emotion it’s so desperately seeking.

The musical numbers are fine, but they bog down the story and never really push it forward. And at a runtime of nearly 2 and half hours, it’s likely audiences will get anxious. However, visually Phillips succeeds in bold, striking theatrics. But sadly, any good in this movie is going to be overshadowed by the bad. The first Joker was critically acclaimed for its realistic portrayal of a Batman villain with mental health issues who we understood and sometimes empathized with. It was so good, Pheonix won his first Oscar for it. So, to go from that film to this somewhat random musical is an unfortunate miss.

Joker Folie a Deux will likely not be everyone’s cup of tea and moviegoers should set low expectations for the plot but have fair expectations for the vocals and performances by Pheonix and Gaga. If you’re fan of the Batman universe, or even more so a fan of The Joker, you’ll still be curious and want to form your own opinion.

“Joker: Folie a Deux” opens in theaters October 4, 2024.